I first heard this song expertedly creepily used in the game "Alice is Dead" by Hyptosis on Newgrounds. I'm never tired of that game for that exact reason. So, I searched for the song on the internet and even on its own it's so creepy that I'm never tired of it.
August 13, 2008 Subject:
Hush, hush, hush Here comes the bogey man
This was the "B" side to The Teddy Bear's Picnic, my favourite childhood record. It was an old 78. Our player would play at 16rpm - which made this sound doubly scary! I had four older sisters and one of them found it a great game to play this record slowly. I ran away and hid in our grain store. A formative experience.
Listening to it now - it still is quite scary at the normal speed.